Earthquake at the Museum

The exhibition Nature Unleashed, now showing at the museum, explores the forces of nature through natural disasters. For many employees of the museum, the exhibition also recalls a local earthquake of a couple of years ago.

First came the rumble of noise and motion. And then, the lights started shaking. That’s when they knew it was an earthquake.

When the magnitude 5.0 quake struck the museum’s massive stone building in late June 2010, it also rattled many of the staff—both literally and metaphorically.

The thinhorn-sheep (Ovis dalli) diorama with the fallen sheep.

In order for the restorer to work in the tight confines of the thinhorn sheep (Ovis dalli) diorama, walkways had to be constructed to keep his weight off the fake rocks. Image: Marcie Kwindt © Canadian Museum of Nature

Fortunately, no-one was hurt and physical effects were minor. One staff member was left dizzy from the 30 seconds of movement and the sight of walls shaking around him. Another staffer on the top floor (where the movement was greatest) felt ill and had trouble regaining her balance for the next half hour.

Emotional balances also took a hit, and for some, the upset lingered. Acutely aware of the exposed lighting grids overhead, the reputation of masonry for breaking not bending, and the deposit of unstable Leda clay lurking directly under the building, some staff were a bit scared, while others were terrified. A former San Franciscan found it more exciting than frightening. Visitors seemed to generally take it in stride; some stepped outside, while others simply rode it out.

Although they didn’t know it at the time, the 100-year-old building had never experienced an earthquake this large. Indeed, the shaking was the strongest that Ottawa has experienced in the last 200 years, if not ever.

Installation of a steel structural frame in a gallery under renovation.

To install the steel skeleton, the entire museum was gutted to the masonry. Image: © PKG Joint Venture Architects

The timing could not have been better. It had been only 32 days since the museum’s grand reopening following renovations that were undertaken to install a steel skeleton inside the stone walls as reinforcement against earthquakes.

Collage of three views of the museum showing the original tower (archive photo CMN15276), the base after the tower was removed, and the new tower.

Left to right: The original tower, the entrance at the base after 80 feet of tower was removed, and the new Queens’ Lantern. Image: public domain, Martin Lipman © Canadian Museum of Nature

The risk was very real. Leda clay’s high water content makes it prone to liquefying when disturbed, such as by larger earthquake vibrations. Even without tremors, the clay had been causing significant problems because the weight of all that stone doesn’t sit well on the clay. Uneven settling had caused cracks in walls, floors and foundations (one large enough to fit a person). It also proved fatal to the original tower: by 1915, the sinking was so great, the tower had started to pull away from the building and had to be removed.

We hate to think what could have happened had the earthquake struck before the structural upgrade, but as it was, the museum got off lightly. As for the building, only a few superficial cracks formed in walls near archways. Among the exhibits, almost 30 minerals were knocked over or jostled, some bird eggs rolled off their nests, a leg and a head of two taxidermy mounts were almost broken off, and a mineral broke. Fortunately, all could be mended, and the almost-invisible mineral repair actually improved on an earlier fix.

A mineral fallen off its mount in the display case.

Several minerals had small pieces broken off when they fell from their mount, but the losses were not worth repairing. Image: Marcie Kwindt © Canadian Museum of Nature

One staff member also came out the better for it. He’d always been nervous about the building’s situation, so when the quake came, it was a kind of test for him. It was such a relief that the engineering of the retrofit really worked, it allowed him to let go of his concerns. “It was an important day in my life because the construction was long, and we saw the results.”

A black case on the floor in a corridor, plugged into a wall socket.

The Etna station records ground acceleration for two perpendicular components (north–south, east–west) and one vertical component. Image: Martin Leclerc © Canadian Museum of Nature

The study of earthquakes is not part of the museum’s research programme, but in 2003, the Geological Survey of Canada installed monitoring equipment in our sub-basement. The device is called an Etna station and it measures acceleration in ground movement. (Seismographs, by contrast, measure velocity). Read the official reports on the earthquake.

Low-angle view along a crack in the road that has swallowed a wagon.

A fissure in one of San Francisco’s streets caused by the earthquake of April 18, 1906. Image: © The Field Museum

And, you can learn more about earthquakes in the special exhibition Nature Unleashed, at the museum until May 4, 2013. The section on earthquakes features some real doozies, such as the Great San Francisco Earthquake of 1906. Our moderate earthquake is definitely not in the same category!

This entry was posted in Architecture, Events, Exhibitions, History and tagged . Bookmark the permalink.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s